Sweet Dreams #33, Dear Amanda, Rosemary Vernon, 1983
Everyone's wondering who is behind "Dear Amanda," the new advice column in the school paper. Everyone, that is, but Tina.
Tina loves playing Amanda. She's excited about her mysterious new identity, and thrilled by the success of her columnstudents really are taking her advice! But something is still missing from her lifethat special feeling for one particular boy. How can she be so unhappy when things are going so well, Tina wonders. Is she asking for too much? Why are other people's problems so much easier to solve than her own?
This story didn't grab me. I skimmed through the book and was never interested.
Sweet Dreams #34, Country Girl, Melinda Pollowitz, 1983
Edie falls for Sean as soon as she sets eyes on him. But soon after they begin dating, he suddenly drops her for another girl. Hurt and angry, Edie thinks she'll never be able to forget him.
Then she meets Jake. Fun-loving and caring, he makes Edie feel warm and happy inside. They spend long, happy days laughing together and taking quiet walks in the country. Part of Edie is sure that Jake is the boy for her, but after losing Sean, she's awfully frightened. Can Jake's feeling for her really be as strong and true as he claims? Can she learn to give her heart again?
This summary makes it sound like Edie's relationship with Sean was a really big deal. They only saw each other a couple of times. The summary hugely exaggerates the importance of the relationship.
The summary is also misleading about Edie and Jake. Edie isn't frightened; she wants Jake to feel something for her, but she's worried that Jake is interested in her older sister. The summary is pure fiction.
Edie wants to feel a "zing" with Jake. My observation is that I needed to feel a "zing" as well, and I never felt it. This story is blah. I read most of the book, but it is not very compelling.
A blog for vintage series books like Nancy Drew and the Hardy Boys... featuring modern middle-grade fantasy... modern young adult novels... vintage teen books... vintage book collecting, buying, and selling topics... and more.
Wednesday, February 19, 2020
Friday, February 14, 2020
Sweet Dreams #31 Too Close for Comfort and #32 Daydreamer
Sweet Dreams #31, Too Close for Comfort, Debra Spector, 1983
For years Drea and Derek have been best friends. They've climbed trees together, played baseball together, and gotten in trouble together. They've always loved each other, but when Derek asks Drea for a date, their feelings grow stronger, until finally they're in love.
Then things start going sour for Drea. Is it because Derek's becoming so possessive? Or because Sam Hennessey's getting interested in her? Suddenly Drea's not quite sure she wants Derek as a boyfriend. Should they break up? And if they do, can they ever be friends again?
The summary reveals enough that I knew that the relationship would be doomed. For that reason, I did not find the book to be that compelling. I could tell that the relationship did not have the necessary ingredients for a lasting romantic relationship. However, the book is interesting enough that I read it all the way through.
Sweet Dreams #32, Daydreamer, Janet Quin-Harkin, 1983
When Lisa's parents split up, she has to leave glamorous Hollywood, her father, and her movie-star motherto live with a grandmother she hardly knows. How can she ever be happy again?
All too often, Lisa finds herself escaping into daydreamsdreams of fame, friends, and boyfriends galore, Hollywood, her parents, and falling in love. But when her fantasy bubble bursts, she has to open her eyes to the fact that, in real life, things don't always work out they way they do in dreams.
On page 53, Lisa has embellished the truth about her life in Hollywood. When Lisa's friend tells her how much she wants to go to Hollywood, Lisa feels bad about the lie. So often in these books, the girls feel no remorse about lying, which is wrong. I tend not to like those books. It is refreshing for a girl to realize that she shouldn't have lied.
I enjoyed this book.
For years Drea and Derek have been best friends. They've climbed trees together, played baseball together, and gotten in trouble together. They've always loved each other, but when Derek asks Drea for a date, their feelings grow stronger, until finally they're in love.
Then things start going sour for Drea. Is it because Derek's becoming so possessive? Or because Sam Hennessey's getting interested in her? Suddenly Drea's not quite sure she wants Derek as a boyfriend. Should they break up? And if they do, can they ever be friends again?
The summary reveals enough that I knew that the relationship would be doomed. For that reason, I did not find the book to be that compelling. I could tell that the relationship did not have the necessary ingredients for a lasting romantic relationship. However, the book is interesting enough that I read it all the way through.
Sweet Dreams #32, Daydreamer, Janet Quin-Harkin, 1983
When Lisa's parents split up, she has to leave glamorous Hollywood, her father, and her movie-star motherto live with a grandmother she hardly knows. How can she ever be happy again?
All too often, Lisa finds herself escaping into daydreamsdreams of fame, friends, and boyfriends galore, Hollywood, her parents, and falling in love. But when her fantasy bubble bursts, she has to open her eyes to the fact that, in real life, things don't always work out they way they do in dreams.
On page 53, Lisa has embellished the truth about her life in Hollywood. When Lisa's friend tells her how much she wants to go to Hollywood, Lisa feels bad about the lie. So often in these books, the girls feel no remorse about lying, which is wrong. I tend not to like those books. It is refreshing for a girl to realize that she shouldn't have lied.
I enjoyed this book.
Wednesday, February 12, 2020
Sweet Dreams #29 Never Love a Cowboy and #30 Little White Lies
Sweet Dreams #29, Never Love a Cowboy, Jesse DuKore, 1982
Bitsy is thrilled when she moves from crowded New York City to colorful Austin, Texas, and even more thrilled when she sees handsome Billy Joe riding his horse to school. For Bitsy, it's love at first sight.
But even when Bitsy's new school radio program grabs everyone else's attention, Billy Joe's eye remains on gorgeous Betty Lou. Can a city girl like Bitsy ever win the heart of a Texas cowboy like Billy Joe?
I was biased against this book before I ever started reading it... Wildfire Romance #37 Sing About Us... need I say more?
The book ended up as unbearable as I thought it would be.
Bitsy seems to be intelligent in all scenes except when she is talking to a boy. She is not presented as nervous by the author. It's like Bitsy is too involved in her own interests to know anything about really basic information that anyone her age with half a brain would know. Perhaps the author thought it would be humorous for Bitsy to be dumb around boys, or perhaps the author figured that silly girls with a crush always act that way. Whatever the purpose, Bitsy's behavior around boys is horribly dumb.
Bitsy doesn't know what a bandanna is. She calls a football quarterback a "quarter horse." She calls the football stadium a "ball field." She has to ask who the cheerleaders are. How would a high school student not know about cheerleaders?
I read the first part of the book, began skimming, and then skipped over chunks of pages. The next sentence is a spoiler, so skip it if you think this book might be worth reading. Bitsy actually gets the cowboy as her boyfriend, which I don't understand. Why is the book titled Never Love a Cowboy? It seems like it worked out for dumb Bitsy.
I do not like this book at all.
Sweet Dreams #30, Little White Lies, Lois I. Fisher, 1983
Everyone says Nina has a good imagination, a gift for telling stories. In fact, it's one of her stories that attracts Scott to her. He's one of the Daltonites, the most sophisticated clique in the school. Nina can't believe she's dating him!
But Nina soon finds that the Daltonites don't welcome outsiders. So she impresses Scott's friends with her stories. It's so easy: a little exaggeration here, a white lie there.
I'm doing this for Scott, she thinks. But her lies finally start to catch up with her, and Nina's afraid of losing Scott forever.
The Bobbsey Twins are mentioned on page 4 and again later in the story. The authors of these teen books from the 1980s really like to compare characters to the Bobbsey Twins for some reason.
Nina's lies are so stupid. Her behavior is foolish. I skimmed a lot of the book and overall do not like it.
Bitsy is thrilled when she moves from crowded New York City to colorful Austin, Texas, and even more thrilled when she sees handsome Billy Joe riding his horse to school. For Bitsy, it's love at first sight.
But even when Bitsy's new school radio program grabs everyone else's attention, Billy Joe's eye remains on gorgeous Betty Lou. Can a city girl like Bitsy ever win the heart of a Texas cowboy like Billy Joe?
I was biased against this book before I ever started reading it... Wildfire Romance #37 Sing About Us... need I say more?
The book ended up as unbearable as I thought it would be.
Bitsy seems to be intelligent in all scenes except when she is talking to a boy. She is not presented as nervous by the author. It's like Bitsy is too involved in her own interests to know anything about really basic information that anyone her age with half a brain would know. Perhaps the author thought it would be humorous for Bitsy to be dumb around boys, or perhaps the author figured that silly girls with a crush always act that way. Whatever the purpose, Bitsy's behavior around boys is horribly dumb.
Bitsy doesn't know what a bandanna is. She calls a football quarterback a "quarter horse." She calls the football stadium a "ball field." She has to ask who the cheerleaders are. How would a high school student not know about cheerleaders?
I read the first part of the book, began skimming, and then skipped over chunks of pages. The next sentence is a spoiler, so skip it if you think this book might be worth reading. Bitsy actually gets the cowboy as her boyfriend, which I don't understand. Why is the book titled Never Love a Cowboy? It seems like it worked out for dumb Bitsy.
I do not like this book at all.
Sweet Dreams #30, Little White Lies, Lois I. Fisher, 1983
Everyone says Nina has a good imagination, a gift for telling stories. In fact, it's one of her stories that attracts Scott to her. He's one of the Daltonites, the most sophisticated clique in the school. Nina can't believe she's dating him!
But Nina soon finds that the Daltonites don't welcome outsiders. So she impresses Scott's friends with her stories. It's so easy: a little exaggeration here, a white lie there.
I'm doing this for Scott, she thinks. But her lies finally start to catch up with her, and Nina's afraid of losing Scott forever.
The Bobbsey Twins are mentioned on page 4 and again later in the story. The authors of these teen books from the 1980s really like to compare characters to the Bobbsey Twins for some reason.
Nina's lies are so stupid. Her behavior is foolish. I skimmed a lot of the book and overall do not like it.
Monday, February 10, 2020
Sweet Dreams #27 Too Young for Love and #28 Trusting Hearts
Sweet Dreams #27, Too Young for Love, Gailanne Maravel, 1982
It looks like Tom and Killy's friendship is turning into romance... but then Tom finds out she's two years younger than the other kids at school.
Killy is miserable, until she leaves the whole mess behind, for a glamorous vacation in Italy.
When she gets back, she feels sophisticated and grown up. But will Tom think so, too?
At first I thought that I wouldn't enjoy Killy's trip to Italy, but that is the best part of the book. Killy meets Fabrio in Italy, and it is not a silly romance. Killy and Fabrio are just very good friends, and Fabrio helps Killy grow as a person. When Killy returns home, she is able to handle teasing better.
I enjoyed the fact that the main plot of the book wraps up a few chapters from the end, so the reader gets to enjoy Killy being happy. So many of these books wait until the last one to three pages of the book for the protagonist to be happy, and I feel like that kind of ending is too abrupt.
This is a very good to excellent book.
Sweet Dreams #28, Trusting Hearts, Jocelyn Saal, 1982
When Kathy lands an after-school job as the assistant to the town's veterinarian, she knows she's found a career she'll always love. At the same time, her old friend Dean has become more tender and romantic toward her.
Kathy's overjoyed, until Dean starts resenting the long hours she puts in at the animal hospital, and their new love seems about to fall apart. She'd be lost without Dean, but she loves her new job just as much. Will she have to make a choice between them?
I like this passage from page 171. I removed some words so as not to spoil part of the plot.
This book has none of that. The details about the veterinarian clinic are interesting, and so is everything that Kathy does in her job.
This book is excellent.
It looks like Tom and Killy's friendship is turning into romance... but then Tom finds out she's two years younger than the other kids at school.
Killy is miserable, until she leaves the whole mess behind, for a glamorous vacation in Italy.
When she gets back, she feels sophisticated and grown up. But will Tom think so, too?
At first I thought that I wouldn't enjoy Killy's trip to Italy, but that is the best part of the book. Killy meets Fabrio in Italy, and it is not a silly romance. Killy and Fabrio are just very good friends, and Fabrio helps Killy grow as a person. When Killy returns home, she is able to handle teasing better.
I enjoyed the fact that the main plot of the book wraps up a few chapters from the end, so the reader gets to enjoy Killy being happy. So many of these books wait until the last one to three pages of the book for the protagonist to be happy, and I feel like that kind of ending is too abrupt.
This is a very good to excellent book.
Sweet Dreams #28, Trusting Hearts, Jocelyn Saal, 1982
When Kathy lands an after-school job as the assistant to the town's veterinarian, she knows she's found a career she'll always love. At the same time, her old friend Dean has become more tender and romantic toward her.
Kathy's overjoyed, until Dean starts resenting the long hours she puts in at the animal hospital, and their new love seems about to fall apart. She'd be lost without Dean, but she loves her new job just as much. Will she have to make a choice between them?
I like this passage from page 171. I removed some words so as not to spoil part of the plot.
"He was a fine vet, a good husband and father, a terrific practical joker, and a ------, too. Just like a diamond, see, with lots and lots of facets. That's what makes a person precious, Kathy. That's what makes him interesting."I thought of Wildfire Romance #38 The Searching Heart as I read this book. Both books were published in 1982 and have similar titles. In both books, the protagonist wants to be a veterinarian. The difference is that the Wildfire book is boring, and even worse, the Wildfire story includes three different scenes featuring animals being put to sleep. What the heck?!
This book has none of that. The details about the veterinarian clinic are interesting, and so is everything that Kathy does in her job.
This book is excellent.
Saturday, February 8, 2020
Sweet Dreams #25 Her Secret Self and #26 It Must Be Magic
Sweet Dreams #25 Her Secret Self, Rhondi Villot, 1982
Poor Joanne. She's failing in school, her parents have grounded her and worst of all, Rob has just ditched her for another girl.
But Joanne's got a secretshe's a natural actress. Who else but Brooke Shields could win Rob back? And who but Barbara Walters could get an A in journalism class? Joanne can play them both and lots of other stars as well. And as long as she's acting, things go great.
Now Joanne thinks she's got her problems licked... all she has to do is play a part. But then she meets Cliff and he wants to know the real Joanne. But will she be able to drop her "act" and let Cliff see her secret self?
From page 161:
The first part of the book is overall good. I never like the first part of many of these books due to the excessively stupid behavior of the girl. The last half of the book is very good to excellent.
Poor Joanne. She's failing in school, her parents have grounded her and worst of all, Rob has just ditched her for another girl.
But Joanne's got a secretshe's a natural actress. Who else but Brooke Shields could win Rob back? And who but Barbara Walters could get an A in journalism class? Joanne can play them both and lots of other stars as well. And as long as she's acting, things go great.
Now Joanne thinks she's got her problems licked... all she has to do is play a part. But then she meets Cliff and he wants to know the real Joanne. But will she be able to drop her "act" and let Cliff see her secret self?
From page 161:
"I hate you, Joanne."This is a powerful moment, because the other girl is consumed by hatred. Joanne has done nothing to her, and Joanne's response is perfect.
"Hate me if you have to," Joanne said tiredly. "I'm sorry. There are better things to do this spring than hate anybody."
The first part of the book is overall good. I never like the first part of many of these books due to the excessively stupid behavior of the girl. The last half of the book is very good to excellent.
Sweet Dreams #26, It Must Be Magic, Marian Woodruff, 1982
When her high school holds its annual madcap Genie Week, Kerrie becomes the "master" of the boy of her dreams. Mike Price makes her wishes his commands as shy, studious Kerrie suddenly finds herself one-half of Glenwood High's wildest couple. But will Mike go back to doing gorgeous Marcy's bidding when Genie Week comes to an end? Maybe if Kerrie wishes hard enough, Mike will still be hers when the week is over.
I don't like the premise of a book when it involves the protagonist attempting to steal a boyfriend away from another girl. It's too Jessica Wakefield for my taste, and it's never as much fun in these books. In fact, it's never fun unless Jessica does it.
The author misdirects the reader so effectively that the ending didn't satisfy me at all. I was just taken aback, since I expected a different ending. I didn't like this book very much, but I was able to read most of it
When her high school holds its annual madcap Genie Week, Kerrie becomes the "master" of the boy of her dreams. Mike Price makes her wishes his commands as shy, studious Kerrie suddenly finds herself one-half of Glenwood High's wildest couple. But will Mike go back to doing gorgeous Marcy's bidding when Genie Week comes to an end? Maybe if Kerrie wishes hard enough, Mike will still be hers when the week is over.
I don't like the premise of a book when it involves the protagonist attempting to steal a boyfriend away from another girl. It's too Jessica Wakefield for my taste, and it's never as much fun in these books. In fact, it's never fun unless Jessica does it.
The author misdirects the reader so effectively that the ending didn't satisfy me at all. I was just taken aback, since I expected a different ending. I didn't like this book very much, but I was able to read most of it
Thursday, February 6, 2020
Sweet Dreams #23 Falling in Love Again and #24 The Trouble with Charlie
Sweet Dreams #23, Falling in Love Again, Barbara Conklin, 1982
Mariah's not one of those girls who's never been kissed. She had a boyfriend. Once. It seems like a thousand years ago. But Paul died, and Mariah thinks she'll never find anyone as special again.
She hadn't counted on the school play, though. Somehow her crazy friend Amy ropes her into working on the props. Before she knows it, Mariah's the understudy for the female lead! And she can't help but notice Dan Gordon, the male lead.
When Dan asks her out, Mariah doesn't know what to think. He's sweet and funny and understandingbut she can't forget Paul. His memory always seems to be between them.
Then Dan gets tired of being second best, and Mariah knows she must choosebetween Dan who loves her now, and Paul who loved her first...
This is the sequel to the first Sweet Dreams book, P.S. I Love You.
Most people really like this book. I enjoyed the beginning of the story, but then I gradually lost interest. I found P. S. I Love You to be much more compelling than this book.
Sweet Dreams #24, The Trouble with Charlie, Jaye Ellen, 1982
Here's Charlie. She has two big brothers so her dating life must be terrific. Right? Wrong!
Her brothers act like watch dogs everywhere she goes and all the best guys have been scared off. Now only the wrong guys ask her out. Charlie's about to give up altogether.
Then Charlie gets friendly with Andy, the terrific guy who lives next door. But Andy's always helping her gets dates with other guys. And what's worse, he's her brothers' pal. Boy has Charlie got boy trouble!
This book is overall very good, although Charlie's brothers are extremely annoying.
Mariah's not one of those girls who's never been kissed. She had a boyfriend. Once. It seems like a thousand years ago. But Paul died, and Mariah thinks she'll never find anyone as special again.
She hadn't counted on the school play, though. Somehow her crazy friend Amy ropes her into working on the props. Before she knows it, Mariah's the understudy for the female lead! And she can't help but notice Dan Gordon, the male lead.
When Dan asks her out, Mariah doesn't know what to think. He's sweet and funny and understandingbut she can't forget Paul. His memory always seems to be between them.
Then Dan gets tired of being second best, and Mariah knows she must choosebetween Dan who loves her now, and Paul who loved her first...
This is the sequel to the first Sweet Dreams book, P.S. I Love You.
Most people really like this book. I enjoyed the beginning of the story, but then I gradually lost interest. I found P. S. I Love You to be much more compelling than this book.
Sweet Dreams #24, The Trouble with Charlie, Jaye Ellen, 1982
Here's Charlie. She has two big brothers so her dating life must be terrific. Right? Wrong!
Her brothers act like watch dogs everywhere she goes and all the best guys have been scared off. Now only the wrong guys ask her out. Charlie's about to give up altogether.
Then Charlie gets friendly with Andy, the terrific guy who lives next door. But Andy's always helping her gets dates with other guys. And what's worse, he's her brothers' pal. Boy has Charlie got boy trouble!
This book is overall very good, although Charlie's brothers are extremely annoying.
Tuesday, February 4, 2020
Hidden Clues #7 Judy Bolton Picture Cover Scarcity
Picture cover editions are a favorite format among current series book collectors. The Judy Bolton picture cover books are particularly difficult to acquire. It is believed that most of the Judy Bolton picture cover books went through just one printing, which is why they are so exceedingly hard to find. Also, a bunch of remaindered picture cover copies were turned into library editions, which reduced the number of surviving picture covers.
#30, 31, and 33 were never printed in the picture cover format, so it is impossible to get a complete set of Judy Bolton picture covers.
I rarely ever see Judy Bolton picture covers in stores. I have seen #1, 2, and 3 multiple times. I have seen all of #36-38 at least once and some of them at least twice. I have also seen #11, 18, and 23 one time each. I have never seen any of the other Judy Bolton picture cover books in any stores ever since I began collecting series books in 1991.
Judy Bolton did not switch to picture cover until 1964, two years after Nancy Drew and the other Grosset and Dunlap series made the change. The series ended in 1967, so the picture cover format was only in print for around three years. That is a very short amount of time and is why most all picture covers likely had only one printing. The Judy Bolton series had low sales during the 1960s, which is what led to the demise of the series. It is quite unlikely that the majority of the titles had more than one printing in the picture cover format.
Some Judy Bolton titles were printed later during that three year period than other titles. Grosset and Dunlap would have continued to use existing stock in the dust jacket format before printing any picture cover books. The picture covers that are the most scarce, which is unfortunately a large number of them, probably were not printed until towards 1965 or 1966.
Grosset and Dunlap must have had sufficient copies of #30, 31, and 33 in the dust jacket format to avoid ever needing to print any picture cover editions of those titles. That is why those three do not exist.
As I began this post, I wrote the following paragraph going by memory of what I remembered seeing for sale over the years.
Below, I give the list information for the picture covers. In red, I indicate the list information given in Clarke's Guide to Margaret Sutton's Judy Bolton Mystery Stories for variants that I do not own. In blue, I indicate the list information provided by collectors who own the books with those lists. All lists in black are from books that I have actually seen. Notice that many of the books list to #36, which means that they were probably not printed in the picture cover format until 1965.
#1 1932 text - to #34 back cover and no interior list
#1 1964 text - to #34 back cover and #35 inside
to #34 back cover and #37 inside
to #34 back cover and #38 inside
#2 - to #34 back cover and #34 inside
to #34 back cover and #36 inside
to #34 back cover and #38 inside
#3 - to #34 back cover and #35 inside
to #36 back cover and #36 inside
to #36 back cover and #38 inside
#4 - to #34 back cover and #35 inside
to #34 back cover and #36 inside
#5 - to #34 back cover and no interior list
#6 - to #34 back cover and #34 inside
#7 - to #34 back cover and no interior list
to #36 back cover and #36 inside
to #34 back cover and #37 inside
#8 - to #34 back cover and #34 inside
#9 - to #34 back cover and #34 inside
#10 - to #34 back cover and #35 inside
to #34 back cover and #37 inside
#11 - to #34 back cover and #34 inside
#12 - to #36 back cover and #36 inside
#13 - to #34 back cover and #34 inside
#14 - to #36 back cover and #36 inside
#15 - to #36 back cover and #36 inside
#16 - to #34 back cover and #35 inside
#17 - to #34 back cover and #35 inside
#18 - to #34 back cover and #34 inside
#19 - to #34 back cover and no interior list
#20 - to #34 back cover and #34 inside
#21 - to #36 back cover and #36 inside
#22 - to #34 back cover and #35 inside
#23 - to #34 back cover and #35 inside
#24 - to #36 back cover and #36 inside
#25 - to #34 back cover and #35 inside
#26 - to #34 back cover and #34 inside
#27 - to #34 back cover and #35 inside
#28 - to #36 back cover and #36 inside
#29 - to #34 back cover and #34 inside
#30 - does not exist
#31 - does not exist
#32 - to #34 back cover and #34 inside
#33 - does not exist
#34 - to #36 back cover and #37 inside
#35 - to #34 back cover and #34 inside
to #34 back cover and #35 inside
#36 - to #36 back cover and #36 inside
#37 - to #34 back cover and #37 inside
#38 - to #34 back cover and #38 inside
This information reveals that #1 had at least four printings. #2, 3, and 7 had at least three printings. #4, 10, and 35 had at least two printings each.
This information confirms what I suspected. I find it especially interesting to confirm two printings of #35. I have always considered #35 to be more common than the other high-numbered titles and have wondered about it. Now I know that #35 did have more than one printing.
I completed my set of Judy Bolton picture covers in the early 2000s. I spent at least $30 each for 19 of the books. 7 of the books cost between $20 and $30. Most series books have gone down in value since that time. The Judy Bolton picture cover values have not gone down, for the most part, due to the extreme scarcity of the books. The value of #34-38 has decreased substantially due to reprints, but the titles that exist from #4 through #32 still retain value that is close to their historical value. People who want a set of Judy Bolton picture cover books must be willing to pay high prices for some of the books in order to complete the set.
#30, 31, and 33 were never printed in the picture cover format, so it is impossible to get a complete set of Judy Bolton picture covers.
I rarely ever see Judy Bolton picture covers in stores. I have seen #1, 2, and 3 multiple times. I have seen all of #36-38 at least once and some of them at least twice. I have also seen #11, 18, and 23 one time each. I have never seen any of the other Judy Bolton picture cover books in any stores ever since I began collecting series books in 1991.
Judy Bolton did not switch to picture cover until 1964, two years after Nancy Drew and the other Grosset and Dunlap series made the change. The series ended in 1967, so the picture cover format was only in print for around three years. That is a very short amount of time and is why most all picture covers likely had only one printing. The Judy Bolton series had low sales during the 1960s, which is what led to the demise of the series. It is quite unlikely that the majority of the titles had more than one printing in the picture cover format.
Some Judy Bolton titles were printed later during that three year period than other titles. Grosset and Dunlap would have continued to use existing stock in the dust jacket format before printing any picture cover books. The picture covers that are the most scarce, which is unfortunately a large number of them, probably were not printed until towards 1965 or 1966.
Grosset and Dunlap must have had sufficient copies of #30, 31, and 33 in the dust jacket format to avoid ever needing to print any picture cover editions of those titles. That is why those three do not exist.
As I began this post, I wrote the following paragraph going by memory of what I remembered seeing for sale over the years.
#1 had at least two printings, since it has two different cover art and text versions. #2, 3, and 4 might have gone through more than one printing since they aren't as hard to find as all later titles. #5-29, #32, and #34 are quite hard to find, so I believe that they all had one printing each. For some reason, I find that #35 through #38 are just slightly easier to find than most picture covers, but they almost certainly would have had just one printing each since they were printed late in the set.I then decided to see if I could find evidence of multiple printings of any titles, in particular #1 through 4.
Below, I give the list information for the picture covers. In red, I indicate the list information given in Clarke's Guide to Margaret Sutton's Judy Bolton Mystery Stories for variants that I do not own. In blue, I indicate the list information provided by collectors who own the books with those lists. All lists in black are from books that I have actually seen. Notice that many of the books list to #36, which means that they were probably not printed in the picture cover format until 1965.
#1 1932 text - to #34 back cover and no interior list
#1 1964 text - to #34 back cover and #35 inside
to #34 back cover and #37 inside
to #34 back cover and #38 inside
#2 - to #34 back cover and #34 inside
to #34 back cover and #36 inside
to #34 back cover and #38 inside
#3 - to #34 back cover and #35 inside
to #36 back cover and #36 inside
to #36 back cover and #38 inside
#4 - to #34 back cover and #35 inside
to #34 back cover and #36 inside
#5 - to #34 back cover and no interior list
#6 - to #34 back cover and #34 inside
#7 - to #34 back cover and no interior list
to #36 back cover and #36 inside
to #34 back cover and #37 inside
#8 - to #34 back cover and #34 inside
#9 - to #34 back cover and #34 inside
#10 - to #34 back cover and #35 inside
to #34 back cover and #37 inside
#11 - to #34 back cover and #34 inside
#12 - to #36 back cover and #36 inside
#13 - to #34 back cover and #34 inside
#14 - to #36 back cover and #36 inside
#15 - to #36 back cover and #36 inside
#16 - to #34 back cover and #35 inside
#17 - to #34 back cover and #35 inside
#18 - to #34 back cover and #34 inside
#19 - to #34 back cover and no interior list
#20 - to #34 back cover and #34 inside
#21 - to #36 back cover and #36 inside
#22 - to #34 back cover and #35 inside
#23 - to #34 back cover and #35 inside
#24 - to #36 back cover and #36 inside
#25 - to #34 back cover and #35 inside
#26 - to #34 back cover and #34 inside
#27 - to #34 back cover and #35 inside
#28 - to #36 back cover and #36 inside
#29 - to #34 back cover and #34 inside
#30 - does not exist
#31 - does not exist
#32 - to #34 back cover and #34 inside
#33 - does not exist
#34 - to #36 back cover and #37 inside
#35 - to #34 back cover and #34 inside
to #34 back cover and #35 inside
#36 - to #36 back cover and #36 inside
#37 - to #34 back cover and #37 inside
#38 - to #34 back cover and #38 inside
This information reveals that #1 had at least four printings. #2, 3, and 7 had at least three printings. #4, 10, and 35 had at least two printings each.
This information confirms what I suspected. I find it especially interesting to confirm two printings of #35. I have always considered #35 to be more common than the other high-numbered titles and have wondered about it. Now I know that #35 did have more than one printing.
I completed my set of Judy Bolton picture covers in the early 2000s. I spent at least $30 each for 19 of the books. 7 of the books cost between $20 and $30. Most series books have gone down in value since that time. The Judy Bolton picture cover values have not gone down, for the most part, due to the extreme scarcity of the books. The value of #34-38 has decreased substantially due to reprints, but the titles that exist from #4 through #32 still retain value that is close to their historical value. People who want a set of Judy Bolton picture cover books must be willing to pay high prices for some of the books in order to complete the set.
Sunday, February 2, 2020
Sweet Dreams #21 All's Fair in Love and #22 Secret Identity
Sweet Dreams #21, All's Fair in Love, Jeanne Andrews, 1982
When Anne moves to glamorous New York City, she meets Greg at an exclusive athletic club... and he's pretty special. But Anne's afraid she won't be able to win Greg's heart. After all, she's only a beginner and Greg likes winnersjust like his sister Sarah, the club's champion gymnast.
Then Anne challenges Sarah for the championship. She's determined to show Greg that she's a winner too. But if she fails, will she lose everythingincluding Greg?
From page 55:
Sweet Dreams #22, Secret Identity, Joanna Campbell, 1982
When Jena Maxwell meets Eric Bliss, she forgets her disappointment about not going to Europe for the summer, forgets everything that has been upsetting her. Eric is gentle, handsome, and Jena's falling deeply in love.
But as their fabulous summer passes, Jena begins to wonder about Eric: why is he so mysterious? Where's his family, his friends?
Then Jena learns the truth about Eric, and her beautiful summer of happiness and love is shattered.
When Anne moves to glamorous New York City, she meets Greg at an exclusive athletic club... and he's pretty special. But Anne's afraid she won't be able to win Greg's heart. After all, she's only a beginner and Greg likes winnersjust like his sister Sarah, the club's champion gymnast.
Then Anne challenges Sarah for the championship. She's determined to show Greg that she's a winner too. But if she fails, will she lose everythingincluding Greg?
From page 55:
"You're entering a gymnastics competition to prove to Greg that you're better than his sister? Isn't that just the slightest bit insane?"That sums up the book. Anne is an idiot, and I don't like her. The story is okay, but Anne is too stupid for words.
Sweet Dreams #22, Secret Identity, Joanna Campbell, 1982
When Jena Maxwell meets Eric Bliss, she forgets her disappointment about not going to Europe for the summer, forgets everything that has been upsetting her. Eric is gentle, handsome, and Jena's falling deeply in love.
But as their fabulous summer passes, Jena begins to wonder about Eric: why is he so mysterious? Where's his family, his friends?
Then Jena learns the truth about Eric, and her beautiful summer of happiness and love is shattered.
I like the setting and think that the story is probably good, but it didn't really grab me. I decided not to read it.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)














