February 27, 2010: Moving One Step Closer
December 10, 2010: Scarcity of Nancy Drew Lilac Inn First Printing
October 27, 2010: 1930A-1 Nancy Drew Lilac Inn First Printing Book
August 7, 2012: The First Printing of Nancy Drew Lilac Inn
January 29, 2013: An Interesting eBay Nancy Drew Find
September 7, 2014: Nancy Drew #4 Mystery at Lilac Inn 2nd Printing DJ Auction
July 16, 2015: Another Nancy Drew Lilac Inn First Printing DJ
The first printing book for The Mystery at Lilac Inn is very scarce. While I refer to the book as the 1930A-1 book, it is actually both the 1930A-1 and 1930B-2 printing according to Farah's 12th edition. Both the 1930A-1 and 1930B-2 printings of Lilac Inn have the "This Isn't All!" page followed by a post-text ad for 9 Hardy Boys books listing to Great Airport Mystery. The second post-text ad lists 20 Outdoor Girls books to Canoe Trip, and the third post-text ad lists 10 Blythe Girls to Margy's Mysterious Visitor. The post-text ads must be in this exact order to be the 1930A-1/B-2 printing.
I own both the first printing and second printing dust jackets for Lilac Inn. Both jackets were purchased mismatched with later printing books. Over the years, I've noticed that most first and second printing Lilac Inn dust jackets that come up for sale are paired with a later books. It's quite odd. The 1930A-1 book is very elusive, and it's been difficult trying to find books to match with my dust jackets.
Back in May, I got lucky and acquired a pretty nice 1930A-1 Lilac Inn book, which I detailed on Facebook.
The toughest to find Nancy Drew first printing in a bare book without dust jacket is Lilac Inn. It is harder to find than the first printing of Old Clock in a bare book. The 1930A-1 Old Clock book is pretty tough to find, but the Lilac Inn 1930A-1 book is about impossible to find.
I have owned a rough condition 1930A-1 Lilac Inn book since 2012, which I have had paired with my first printing Lilac Inn dust jacket. I saw an online listing for a blank endpapers Lilac Inn, which I purchased simply because it was priced very reasonably (as in well below value). I expected to receive a book that lists to Diary, since that is what usually happens.
When the book arrived, I saw it was a candidate for the first printing. I quickly checked Farah's Guide, which led to disbelief. I checked again. The ads were in the right order. I counted the Outdoor Girls titles. Yes, 20 of them. Wow.
But wait... the internals. The frontispiece was there. I found two internals but couldn't find the third. I pulled down my rough condition copy and found all the internals, noting the page numbers. I again checked the book that had just arrived. I found all of the internals. All four illustrations, present.
The pictures show the book that just arrived followed by the book it will replace. I paid a good bit more for the rough condition book than I did for the upgrade. It always seems to be that way.
I had a dilemma about which book to pair with my dust jackets. I ended up pairing the worse condition first printing book with the first printing jacket, and the better condition first printing book with the second printing dust jacket. I still wasn't satisfied with the situation, but it was better than before. Consider that I acquired my first printing and second printing dust jackets way back in 2010, and I've been working on getting both of them matched with decent first printing books ever since.
On November 4, an auction for the 1930A-1 Lilac Inn book showed up on eBay.
I added the book to my watch list, interested to see what would happen. I thought that several people would bid on the book, so I initially wasn't going to bother. I then reconsidered. I needed another decent first printing book for one of my jackets. I decided that I would bid, just not aggressively. I didn't feel that I had a great chance of winning the auction.
Strangely, I was the only bidder, so I have now acquired another first printing Lilac Inn book. The below photos show the three first printing Lilac Inn books currently in my possession. The book purchased in May is the nicest book and is the book seen on the left. The book just purchased is in the middle. The third book was purchased in 2012, detailed in this post.
On November 4, an auction for the 1930A-1 Lilac Inn book showed up on eBay.
I added the book to my watch list, interested to see what would happen. I thought that several people would bid on the book, so I initially wasn't going to bother. I then reconsidered. I needed another decent first printing book for one of my jackets. I decided that I would bid, just not aggressively. I didn't feel that I had a great chance of winning the auction.
Strangely, I was the only bidder, so I have now acquired another first printing Lilac Inn book. The below photos show the three first printing Lilac Inn books currently in my possession. The book purchased in May is the nicest book and is the book seen on the left. The book just purchased is in the middle. The third book was purchased in 2012, detailed in this post.
The book with the gouge in the spine would be the nicest book, but it has a gouge in the spine. The gouge is a significant flaw that causes it not to be the nicest of the three books.
I'm pairing the overall nicest book with my first printing jacket. The book with the gouge in the spine will be paired with my second printing jacket. The book purchased in 2012 will be sold eventually. When I wrote about my 2012 first printing book purchase, I ended the post with this statement:
Does this end my search for the first printing of Lilac Inn? I wish I could say that it did, but I will continue my search. Not only would I like a better condition book, but I also need another book to go with my second printing dust jacket. Both the first and second printing dust jackets need the first printing book in order to be a perfect match.
It took 14 years and 3 months to find two better condition books for my jackets. It's odd that I found both just six months apart during the same year. While I could still stand to have nicer books, I have probably now reached the end of my hunt for the first printing Lilac Inn book.
1930A-1 jacket matched with the 1930A-1/B-2 book:
1930B-2 jacket matched with the 1930A-1/B-2 book:
I've never been a collector who needs for everything to be perfect. Therefore, I am satisfied with having these two books matched with my dust jackets.









No comments:
Post a Comment